After five years, Google still doesn’t know how to rank images

Author avatar

Emma Barnes

As a Data Analyst with my own blog; naturally, I’m always intrigued to check out some of the keywords that bring people to my site.

Focusing on video games, my blog attracts some pretty random keywords, take a look at this one I found the other day:

photo emo pretty boys google analytics

So, I decided to check it out for myself. By using the Google image tracking filter AJ Kohn wrote about, I was able to tell this came from image search. So before long, I was searching for photos of ‘pretty emo boys’ to see what image was ranking.

photos of pretty emo boys google image search

The picture is of Squall, the main character from Final Fantasy VIII. It seems unsurprising, because I wrote a review of Final Fantasy VIII some time ago.

However, this picture doesn’t appear anywhere in the review. But in this paragraph I do in fact link out to that picture.

Final Fantasy VIII review screenshot

The link is to this image of said ’emo’ pretty boy, which is not hosted on my blog.

So, why am I ranking in image search for an image I don’t even host?

Of course, Patrick Altoft comes up with the answer in about a second after seeing the question.

You don’t need to have the image on your page, a link to the image is enough for Google to think the image is there.

In fact, he wrote a post about this… back in 2007!

So now you have it, nearly six years on, and Google still has no idea how to credit images to the right people.

I know this is a lame problem to have in the grand scheme of online marketing, but it’s not exactly clever on Google’s part. My blog receiving the traffic means that the original owners of the image are not getting the traffic. Not only that, but if a user clicks through to my site, they’ll see that the image isn’t there, and think “what am I do on this page?” and bounce right back.

If anyone else has seen this, I’d like to hear about it. I’m on Twitter @ejbarnes89 or you can leave a comment in the section below.


+44 (0) 1225 480 480

20 Manvers Street




+44 (0) 113 260 4010

2nd floor, 2180 Century Way,

Thorpe Park,

Leeds, LS15 8ZB.


+44 (0) 113 260 4010

5th Floor, Cordy House,

91 Curtain Road

London, EC2A 3BS

Part of the St. Ives Group

  • By pressing submit you consent for Edit to contact you via your email or telephone number for purposes relevant to your request for our goods or services. Your contact details, including your name, company, telephone number and email address will be used by Edit. By contacting you are agreeing to Edit’s Privacy Policy. If you have any questions, please ensure you review this section before submitting.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

© 2018 Edit. St Ives Group. Company reg. no. 3624881, All rights reserved. VAT Registered GB 927458295 Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Cookie Policy